How to compare security guard management software in 2026: a weighted scorecard and demo test plan

How to compare security guard management software in 2026: a weighted scorecard, a worked scoring example and 12 demo tests with pass criteria.

  • StrataMax team
  • 10 min read
  • 4 sources
On this page

Figures in this article are checked as of 15 November 2026. Rules change with each budget and gazette notice, so confirm current rates with the IRD, SSF or your tax adviser before you rely on them.

The best security guard management software in 2026 is not a product name. It is whichever option scores highest on a weighted scorecard built around your company’s priorities, after it has passed live tests run on your own data. A company with 800 guards and heavy month-end payroll needs different strengths from a company with 60 guards spread across remote posts.

This article gives you the method: how to weight the criteria, how to score vendors on the same scale, a worked scoring example, twelve demo tests with pass criteria, and how to compare total cost. If you are still deciding what to require, start with our buyer’s checklist for security guard management software in Nepal. This article picks up where that one ends: you have a shortlist, and now you need to compare it.

Why is there no single “best” guard management software?

Because “best” depends on where your company loses the most time and money. Three examples:

  • A large guard company with hundreds of guards, a few big clients and monthly SSF and TDS filings. Payroll accuracy and approvals matter most.
  • A smaller company with many remote posts. Field supervision, the mobile app and patrol visits matter most.
  • An outsourcing company placing cleaners, drivers and office assistants at many clients. Per-client payroll and billing matter most.

A ranked list on a website cannot know which of these you are. A scorecard can, because you set the weights.

How should you weight the evaluation criteria?

Write the weights down before the first demo, and get the owner, the accountant and the operations head to agree on them. Weights decided after a polished demo tend to follow the demo.

Here is a starting point for a security guard company. The weights add up to 100. Change them to fit your business.

Area What it covers Suggested weight
Payroll accuracy SSF on basic, TDS on FY 2083/84 slabs, overtime, Dashain allowance, salary revisions 25
Billing and IRD IRD-approved VAT invoices, CBMS reporting, credit notes, receipts with TDS withheld 15
Operations structure Clients, posts, shifts, dated assignments 15
Mobile app and attendance Check-in and check-out, location checks, leave requests 10
Field operations Patrol visits, incidents, equipment issue and return 10
Controls Roles and permissions, payroll approval, change history 10
Data import and setup Excel import, setup help 5
Support and updates Month-end support, rule updates when laws change 10
Total 100

An outsourcing company might move 5 points from field operations to billing. A company with remote posts might move 5 points from billing to the mobile app.

Which criteria should be gates, not weights?

Some failures cannot be outweighed by strengths elsewhere. Treat these as gates: a vendor that fails any of them is out, whatever its total.

  • SSF calculated on the wrong base, such as gross pay instead of basic remuneration.
  • TDS on last year’s slabs, or no way to update slabs when the Finance Act changes.
  • No payroll approval step before payment.
  • Billing software that is not IRD-approved, if your business must issue invoices electronically and report them to CBMS.
  • No way to export your own data.

How do you score each vendor?

Use one scale for every row and every vendor, and score only what you saw working, not what was promised for a later release.

Score Meaning
0 Not available, or failed the test
1 Available but needs a workaround or a manual step every month
2 Works for the test, with minor gaps
3 Works for the test, including your edge cases

The weighted score is the sum of weight × score for each area, divided by 3 so that a perfect vendor scores 100.

Worked example: two vendors

Two vendors both pass the gates. Here are their scores from the demos and tests.

Area Weight Vendor A score A weighted Vendor B score B weighted
Payroll accuracy 25 3 75 2 50
Billing and IRD 15 2 30 3 45
Operations structure 15 3 45 2 30
Mobile app and attendance 10 2 20 3 30
Field operations 10 1 10 3 30
Controls 10 3 30 1 10
Data import and setup 5 2 10 3 15
Support and updates 10 2 20 2 20
Sum 100 240 230
Score out of 100 80.00 76.67

The arithmetic: 240 ÷ 3 = 80.00 and 230 ÷ 3 = 76.67.

Vendor A wins on these weights because its payroll and controls are stronger. Vendor B has better field tools but scored 1 on controls, which means a workaround is needed to stop the wrong person approving payroll. For a payroll-heavy company that is a real risk.

Now re-weight for a company with many remote posts: move 10 points from payroll accuracy to field operations (payroll 15, field operations 20). Vendor A: 240 − (10 × 3) + (10 × 1) = 220, or 73.33. Vendor B: 230 − (10 × 2) + (10 × 3) = 240, or 80.00. The order flips. That is the point of agreeing weights first.

What tests should you run in a demo?

Send the tests to every vendor at least a few days in advance, with your own sample data. Ask them to run each one live, not on slides. Write the pass criterion before the demo so you are not persuaded afterwards.

# Test Pass criterion
1 SSF for a guard on NPR 12,170 basic and 7,380 dearness Employee 1,338.70 and employer 2,434.00, on basic only
2 TDS for a supervisor with NPR 12,00,000 annual taxable income, SSF contributor NPR 20,000 for the year (0% on the first 10 lakh, 10% on the next 2 lakh), 1,666.67 a month
3 The same supervisor, not an SSF contributor NPR 30,000 for the year (1% band applies), 2,500.00 a month
4 10 hours of overtime on a shift whose overtime rate is set at NPR 120 an hour NPR 1,200.00, and you can see where the rate came from
5 A guard tries to check in from outside the post’s site area The check-in is flagged or refused, and the office can see it
6 A salary revision effective from the 16th of the month Pay split correctly before and after; the old rate kept in history
7 A leave request sent from a guard’s phone Request reaches the approver; approved leave shows in payroll
8 A patrol officer visits a post and records a finding Visit shows findings, conclusion, photos, and start and end location
9 An incident at a post with a follow-up action Incident has a severity, a follow-up with an owner, and a closed status
10 A guard resigns with a uniform and torch not returned Outstanding equipment shows before the final settlement
11 An invoice with a wrong amount Credit note against the original; original kept; both reported to IRD where required
12 An approved payroll batch needs a correction Unapproval needs a reason; the change is recorded with who and when

Check tests 1 to 3 yourself before the demo. Test 1: 12,170 × 11% = 1,338.70 and 12,170 × 20% = 2,434.00. Test 2: the SSF contributor pays 0% on the first NPR 10,00,000, then 10% on the remaining 2,00,000 = 20,000; 20,000 ÷ 12 = 1,666.67. Test 3: 1% of 10,00,000 = 10,000, plus 20,000 = 30,000; 30,000 ÷ 12 = 2,500.00. Our guide to TDS on salary for FY 2083/84 explains the slabs.

A note on overtime

The Labour Act 2074, section 31(1), sets overtime at 1.5 times the basic remuneration for regular hours. Software handles overtime in different ways: some apply a fixed multiplier, others pay the rate you set on each shift. Neither is wrong as a design, but you need to know which one you are buying and check that the rate you configure matches your policy and the Act. Test 4 tells you whether the rate is visible and controllable.

How do you run a trial after the demo?

A demo shows what the vendor prepared. A trial shows what happens with your data. For the leading one or two vendors:

  1. Pick one client with two or three posts and a manageable number of guards.
  2. Import the real employee records for those guards from your Excel sheet.
  3. Run last month’s payroll for them and compare it line by line with what you actually paid.
  4. Raise last month’s invoice for that client and compare it with the invoice you sent.
  5. Put the app on two or three guards’ phones for a week, including an older Android phone.

Every difference has one of three explanations: a mistake in your old sheet, a setup mistake in the trial, or a gap in the software. Only the third should lower the score. A full rollout is a separate project; our implementation guide for a guard management system covers it.

How do you compare total cost, not just the licence fee?

Pricing models differ between vendors: per guard, per user, per module or a flat fee. Comparing headline prices hides most of the cost. List every item for each vendor over the first year.

Cost item Questions to ask
Licence or subscription How does it change as guards are added or leave?
Setup and configuration Included, or charged separately? Who does it?
Data migration Will the vendor import your Excel data, or must your staff retype it?
Training How many sessions, for whom, and is it repeated for new staff?
Devices Do field staff need Android phones you do not already have?
IRD e-billing If you need it, who helps with the permit from your tax office?
Support Is month-end support included, and how fast is it?
Internal staff time How many hours a month will your office spend on the system, compared with now?

Ask each vendor to put the first two years in writing. A low licence fee with paid setup, paid migration and slow support can cost more than a higher fee that includes them.

What should you ask a vendor’s references?

Ask for two or three references from companies of a similar size and type, then call them. Useful questions:

  • How long did it take before you stopped running Excel in parallel?
  • What went wrong in the first three months, and how was it fixed?
  • When the tax slabs changed for FY 2083/84, how quickly was the software updated?
  • How does support respond in the last week of the month?
  • Would you choose the same software again?

What are the red flags during an evaluation?

  • The vendor will not run your test data, only its own demo account.
  • Answers like “that is on the roadmap” for a gate item.
  • SSF or TDS figures that do not match your own calculation, with no clear explanation.
  • No way to see who changed a salary or an invoice.
  • Vague answers about IRD approval. IRD lists billing software and grants e-billing permits to each taxpayer; ask to see the listing and how the permit process works.
  • Savings figures promised before the vendor has seen your data.

Evaluation checklist

  • Weights agreed by owner, accountant and operations head before any demo.
  • Gates written down: SSF base, current-year TDS, payroll approval, IRD-approved billing if required, data export.
  • The 12 demo tests sent in advance, with sample data and pass criteria.
  • Tests 1 to 3 calculated by your accountant before the demo.
  • Every vendor scored on the same 0 to 3 scale, from what was seen working.
  • Weighted scores calculated and checked by a second person.
  • Ranking re-checked with a different weighting to see if it holds.
  • Trial run for the leading vendor with one client’s real data.
  • First-year and second-year total cost in writing from each vendor.
  • At least two references called.

Where StrataMax fits

StrataMax is one of the options you can put through this scorecard. It is built in Kathmandu for security guard and outsourcing companies. It covers payroll with SSF, TDS, overtime, Dashain allowance, salary revisions, approvals and version history; IRD-approved VAT billing with CBMS reporting, credit notes and receipts with TDS withheld; clients, posts and assignments; equipment, patrol visits and incidents; and an Android app for field staff for assignments, check-in and check-out against the site area, leave requests and patrol visits. Book a demo and send us the twelve tests above first.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best security guard management software in 2026?

There is no single best product for every company. The best one for you is the option that scores highest on a weighted scorecard built around your own priorities, after it has passed live tests run on your own data, such as your payroll, your posts and your client invoices.

How do you compare security guard management software fairly?

Agree the criteria and their weights before any demo, score every vendor on the same 0 to 3 scale using only what you saw working, and treat a small set of must-haves as gates that disqualify a vendor regardless of its total score. Then check the leading option in a short trial with your own data.

What should a demo of guard management software include?

Scripted tests that you send in advance: an SSF and TDS calculation for FY 2083/84, overtime at a shift's set rate, a check-in from outside the site area, a salary revision, a patrol visit, an incident with follow-ups, an equipment return on resignation, and an invoice corrected with a credit note. Each test should have a pass criterion you wrote before the demo.

How much does security guard management software cost?

Pricing models differ between vendors, so compare the total cost of ownership rather than the headline licence fee. Include setup, data migration, training, Android phones for field staff, support at month end and the staff time the system saves or adds.

Sources

  1. Social Security Fund: amount to be deposited in the fund (contribution rates)
  2. Inland Revenue Department: tax rates for natural persons, income year 2083/084
  3. Labour Act 2074, Nepal Law Commission English translation
  4. Inland Revenue Department: notice on electronic invoices and CBMS (2083/01/03)

Next step

Let StrataMax do this every month

Payroll with SSF and TDS, IRD-approved billing and every guard and post on one record. Book a 30-minute walkthrough.